Add Memory | Add To Friends
phil-himself (profile) wrote,
on 6-5-2009 at 8:37pm
Subject: Dark Knight Plot Hole?
Everyone remembers when Dent says that he is Batman on TV, well why is that people automatically believed him? Was it because the two were never seen in the same place at at the same time? Believable but a very weak argument. But I can nearly guarantee that they have been seen in different places at the same time. Think about it, a politician running for office is bound to go to a few evening fundraisers, and I say a few loosely, whereas Batman's hours of operations are during that same time frame.

So why did Gotham believe him? Well I think it has to do with mass media, and if this was Nolan's intentions well he is certainly one of the most brilliant filmmakers of our time. A well groomed man in a suit with a smiling face says something outlandish on television and people believe it, no matter how absurd it may be. Everyone believes it because they are being told by every media outlet that it is true.
Post A Comment



jayzulla

06-06-09 12:47pm

I can kind of see what you're getting at. However I think there were a few parts where it could have seemed that Dent was batman. At the dinner when wayne knocks himout and hides him, then batman shows up to confront the joker. i think dent was going for more of the quick fix though then to trick everyone into actually thinking he was batman. either way, movie was awesome.

(reply to this)


phil-himself

Re:, 06-06-09 1:09pm

People didn't even shrug to give it second thought, they just believed it from the horses mouth.

(reply to comment)


this-acoustic-love

Re: Re:, 06-06-09 9:17pm

Phil, it's just a movie. If we pointed out every plot hole in every movie ever, we'd never enjoy anything.

(reply to comment)


phil-himself

Re: Re: Re:, 06-06-09 11:14pm

Did you read past the subject line?
I clearly stated that if Nolan intended to implement this he is a genius

(reply to comment)


this-acoustic-love

Re: Re: Re: Re:, 06-07-09 12:14am

Yes, I read the whole thing, I meant, if it wasn't on purpose.

(reply to comment)


phil-himself

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re:, 06-07-09 12:19am

If it wasn't on purpose I'm still sticking with my idea till someone has a better argument, and I would like to hear it. It's maddening.

(reply to comment)


egotrip

06-06-09 5:42pm

The peeps were also desperate. Desperation can make a person believe anything and do stupid things.

(reply to this)